Were Muslims as enthusiastic as Hindus about Freedom Struggle during British Raj?

[Amogh]

Is it true that Muslims were not as enthusiastic as Hindus about Freedom Struggle during British Raj?

Elaborate your point of view. Post links about it if you know any.

[Amogh]

Err.. Mods should edit and add one option to the poll viz. I don't know.

[MiyaBhai]

Possibly they weren't considerin their Hindu brothers from rss were chamchas of british. They didn't feel like cheating RSS.

[Sane Less]

Originally Posted by MiyaBhai

Possibly they weren't considerin their Hindu brothers from rss were chamchas of british. They didn't feel like cheating RSS.

Rarely do I see a peaceful person praising the trustworthy RSS. I sure hope it is not a grammatical typo Miyasai pai

[MiyaBhai]

Originally Posted by Sane Less

Rarely do I see a peaceful person praising the trustworthy RSS. I sure hope it is not a grammatical typo Miyasai pai

The common ground for two sanghis to fall in love is their mutual admiration for their hatred for muslims.

[Sane Less]

Originally Posted by MiyaBhai

The common ground for two sanghis to fall in love is their mutual admiration for their hatred for muslims.

With that ID name of your's, it does not seem like you have a hatred for the peaceful people. So, I am still trying to understand your statement

[Amogh]

Just yes or no answers? No discussion and no links? Nobody has knowledge about this matter or what?

Okay I will draw conclusions by asking specific questions. Name as many Muslim revolutionaries as you can.

[Sane Less]

Originally Posted by prajapati

... and jis desh mein ganga baheti hai )

Jis desh mein ganga beheti hai is a partition-based movie This is news to me. Are you talking about the Raj Kapoor/Pran starrer... or was there a new one based on partition

[Sane Less]

Originally Posted by prajapati

Watch the movie again,.. when the songs runs,.. " aa aab laut chalein,..... and Pakistanis are moving to pakistaan in bullock-carts and in a desert,.. a miles long row of carts,..... going to pakistan is shown and they even start throwing rocks on an another queue of Hindus - the row which is coming from Pakistan to relocate, in Hindustan.....

It is an old movie and my memory fails... but I always thought it was a movie about rehabilitating a dacait gang. Plan and simple... but would love to watch it again sometime.

[swami]

Originally Posted by prajapati

It was,. but also shows, the climate in villages at the time of Hindustan/Pakistan Division
and one incident was even emphasized if you remember,........ in a poor village family,. a budhdha sleeping on a khatiya denies to go to the Pakistan,.....
he prefers rather being slaughtered over there,.. in riots,..
and to save the life of the son, wife and kids they-family have to finally leave him alone, to be slaughtered in Hindo-muslim riots,..
and they walk away in carts for pakistan moving,..leaving that addiyal budhdha there,..

This song shows the situation of some row of ppl moving,...in mile long queues,.

Kuch bhi fekhne ka ?
Raju (Raj Kapoor) is a poor, friendly orphan who wins his bread by singing songs. One day he sees an injured man and helps him. Later he is kidnapped by few bandits who mistake him to be an undercover policeman. It then turns out that the injured man he helped is the leader (Sardar) of this gang. The Sardar takes good care of Raju and treats him with honour. Sardar's daughter Kammo (Padmini) falls in love with Raju. Kammo and Sardar convince Raju of how they are good bandits who are making sure that wealth is equally distributed amongst people.

On one of the loots, Raju witnesses murder of newlywed couple. He decides to go to police and leaves the gang. One of the bandits, Raka (Pran), kills the Sardar and takes over; he and wishes to forcibly wed Kammo. When Raju tells all truth to police they decide to confront and kill the bandits. Raj begs police to not kill them, but is shunned. Raju is then posed in a dilemma of what to do and finds himself helpless when he sees police stooping just as low to stop crime.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jis_De...Behti_Hai#Plot
The song you posted was a call to surrender to the police force which is being shown entering the village.

[kkkk]

Originally Posted by MiyaBhai

Possibly they weren't considerin their Hindu brothers from rss were chamchas of british. They didn't feel like cheating RSS.

Originally Posted by Sane Less

With that ID name of your's, it does not seem like you have a hatred for the peaceful people. So, I am still trying to understand your statement

I am a really kachha khiladi of english.... I thought Miyabhai bhau was not praising RSS at all! He is praising the character of muslims in not wanting to cheat the Hindus

[Sane Less]

Originally Posted by prajapati

I pull back my words,.. was confused with Rajesh Khanna's movie " Prem Kahani "

...

Prem Kahani was about partition I am very confused now... where do you get your info, Prapajakati pai

Originally Posted by kkkk

I am a really kachha khiladi of english.... I thought Miyabhai bhau was not praising RSS at all! He is praising the character of muslims in not wanting to cheat the Hindus

He claims that RSS were not chamchas of British. That's why they did not feel like cheating them. Which is basically against the religion as their god claims himself to be the best cheater

[sgars]

As per khushwant Singh's autobiography, Muslims were not as enthusiastic about Freedm struggle as Hindus or Sikhs.. Maulana Azad and Ghaffar khan were probably exceptions - So were Jinnah and Iqbal in their earlier days.

There is a piece by Sir Syed on why British rule would be better for Muslims

[kkkk]

Originally Posted by Sane Less

Prem Kahani was about partition I am very confused now... where do you get your info, Prapajakati pai



He claims that RSS were not chamchas of British. That's why they did not feel like cheating them. Which is basically against the religion as their god claims himself to be the best cheater

cant believe giving so much importance to that post.... I suppose two ways to read it...

Possibly they weren't considerin [that]
their Hindu brothers from rss were chamchas of british


Possibly
they weren't considerin their Hindu brothers from rss were chamchas of british

[punkaj]

Muslims are building India, working as labourers and mechanicks, artisans, leather work and everythign