eCharcha.Com   Support eCharcha.Com. Click on sponsor ad to shop online!

Advertise Here

Go Back   eCharcha.Com > Current Affairs > Defense

Notices

Defense Defense and national security...

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old December 20th, 2010, 05:23 AM
ashdoc ashdoc is offline
senior echarchan
 
Join Date: Feb 2009
Posts: 7,954
ashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond repute
New book says Nehru's stubbornness led to war with China in 1962

Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru "shut the door to negotiations on the (India-China) boundary on July 1, 1954", according to a just-released book by A G Noorani based on archival research and hitherto unpublished material.

And this Nehru's refusal to negotiate, and the 1960 rebuff to Chou En-lai when he was visiting and appeared ready to settle the issue may well have sowed the seeds of the 1962 India-China war.

The important and explicit directive, from Nehru, in a 17-para memorandum, cited by Noorani in his book, says: "Both as flowing from our policy and as a consequence of our Agreement with China, this frontier should be considered a firm and definite one which is not open to discussion with anybody. There may be very minor points of discussion. Even these should not be raised by us."

Noorani, an expert on legal and constitutional issues, known for his study of the boundary issue, writes in the book, "India-China Boundary Problem. 1846-1947: History and Diplomacy", that "India unilaterally revised its official map. The legend 'boundary undefined' in the western (Kashmir) and middle sectors (Uttar Pradesh) in the official maps of 1948 and 1950 were dropped in the new map of 1954. A firm clear line was shown instead."

The author says that Nehru's directive of July 1, 1954 was apparently in pursuance of a decision taken on March 24, 1953 to formulate a new line for the boundary. "It was a fateful decision. Old maps were burnt. One former Foreign Secretary told this writer how, as a junior official, he himself was obliged to participate in this fatuous exercise."

It is speculated that the official was Ram Sathe, India's last consul-general in Xinjiang and later Ambassador to China. The book, dedicated to the memory of Sathe, was released on December 16 at the residence of Vice President Hamid Ansari during Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao's visit.

The book mentions that new maps were printed showing Northern and North Eastern frontiers without any reference to any line. Nehru also wanted that these maps should be sent to embassies abroad and introduced to the public generally and be used is schools and colleges.

Describing as "historically untrue" every one of the statements of Nehru in his letter to Chinese Premier Zhou En-lai of March 22, 1959, Noorani states that as late as 1950, Indian maps showed the boundary as undefined.

The unpublished archival material in Chapter 12 titled 'Aftermath', quotes extensively from the 17-page memo and says a "divided Cabinet, an irresponsible opposition, an uninformed press and a restive Parliament, all fed on bad history held Nehru hostage."

Selective excerpts:

"A century-old problem was neglected, by a conscious decision, in 1954. It acquired the dimensions of a boundary dispute in 1959. Unresolved in 1960 when the prospects of a fair settlement were bright, the dispute was sought to be resolved by confrontation. Indias attempt to revise the status quo in 1961 by a Forward Policy in the West came to grief. China decided to settle the matter by recourse to war in October 1962."

"The conclusion is hard to resist that there was a total disconnect between the facts of history and India's policy on the boundary problem and later boundary dispute. Its diplomacy became inflexible because it espoused a policy which barred give and take. Each one of the propositions stated earlier in Chapter XI was flouted the 1842 Treaty; and undefined boundary; the Karakoram boundary; and, worst of all, an impermissible recourse to unilateral change of frontiers."

"This, in a dispute pre-eminently susceptible to a fair solution; for, each had its vital non-negotiable interest securely under its control. India had the McMahon Line while China had the Xinjiang-Tibet road across the Aksai Chin in Ladakh."

"Zhou En-lai was all too ready to accept such a solution during his visit to New Delhi in April 1960. He was rebuffed. China proceeded to practice its own brand of unilateralism, sanctifying territorial gains won by armed force."

"There was nothing inevitable about this impasse. A settlement was possible at the summit in New Delhi in April 1960, despite the fact that public opinion had been ignited over the armed clashes in Longju and the Kongka pass in 1959. A divided Cabinet, an irresponsible opposition, an uninformed press and a restive Parliament, all fed on bad history, held Nehru hostage; not that he had a different view of the past. Had he so willed between January 21 and March 22, 1959 when he replied to Zhous letter, a policy based on the historical truth and sensible diplomacy conducted in private could have charted a route that would assuredly have led to accord."

"But history was scorned and it took its revenge; paving the way to a wild, irrational play of military might and the politics of power to shape a border dispute inherently and pre-eminently susceptible to a fair compromise. The diplomatic consequences of the deepening rift between India and China are incalculable; especially in India's relations with its other neighbours, particularly Pakistan."

The book reveals that the only comprehensive and objective study of the Northern Frontier conducted under the supervision of K. Zakaraiah, director of the Historical Division in the Ministry of External Affairs in 1953 is still kept secret.

The book says that in 1979 Chinese leader Deng Xiaoping had told then Minister of External Affairs Atal Behari Vajpayee, when he was on a visit, to settle on the basis of the status quo of 1980 and not 1960; albeit with minor adjustments.

Read more: Nehru's stubbornness led to 1962 war with China? - The Times of India http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/i...#ixzz18eqbNlgv
__________________
-----
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old December 20th, 2010, 08:05 PM
rationalthinker's Avatar
rationalthinker rationalthinker is offline
Bhai Bolela hai
 
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Maharashtra, India
Posts: 2,338
rationalthinker has a reputation beyond reputerationalthinker has a reputation beyond reputerationalthinker has a reputation beyond reputerationalthinker has a reputation beyond reputerationalthinker has a reputation beyond reputerationalthinker has a reputation beyond reputerationalthinker has a reputation beyond reputerationalthinker has a reputation beyond reputerationalthinker has a reputation beyond reputerationalthinker has a reputation beyond reputerationalthinker has a reputation beyond repute
Re: New book says Nehru's stubbornness led to war with China in 1962

Given this guy's questionable credentials vis-a-vis his take on matters Islamic and Hindu, it is very difficult to accept his arguements and inferences as valid!
Very likely, the info/data cited by him is highly 'edited'!

And we've just seen how, with edited data, even 26/11 can become a 'Hindu conspiracy'!
These types of 'seculars' are particularly insidious and unreliable (rule of thumb: don't believe seculars unless there's corroboration from some foreign source).
__________________
Think Rationally, And then..GO TO H***..!!
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old December 20th, 2010, 09:10 PM
ashdoc ashdoc is offline
senior echarchan
 
Join Date: Feb 2009
Posts: 7,954
ashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond reputeashdoc has a reputation beyond repute
Re: New book says Nehru's stubbornness led to war with China in 1962

how the war started--

http://www.echarcha.com/forum/showthread.php?t=31263

the actual fighting--

http://www.echarcha.com/forum/showthread.php?t=31296
__________________
-----
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old December 20th, 2010, 09:56 PM
pakkidost's Avatar
pakkidost pakkidost is offline
Senior eCharchan
 
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Hum banjaron ki baat mat poocho ji.
Posts: 2,870
pakkidost has a reputation beyond reputepakkidost has a reputation beyond reputepakkidost has a reputation beyond reputepakkidost has a reputation beyond reputepakkidost has a reputation beyond reputepakkidost has a reputation beyond reputepakkidost has a reputation beyond reputepakkidost has a reputation beyond reputepakkidost has a reputation beyond reputepakkidost has a reputation beyond reputepakkidost has a reputation beyond repute
Re: New book says Nehru's stubbornness led to war with China in 1962

Read Brig. John Dalvi's 'Himalayan Blunder" and you will get an first hand idea of 1962 war's who, how and why.

General Kaul and Nehru screwed India and Indian military big time in 62 leading a bloody and shameful defeat.

Himalayan Blunders make you feel embarrassed, angry, sad and disappointed at the same time. I have shed so many tears out of frustration, anger and disgust after reading this book that I don't even touch it now.
__________________


Loud and Proud LLKC member since infinity and beyond

Loud but not so Proud IDLE
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old December 21st, 2010, 06:58 AM
echarcha's Avatar
echarcha echarcha is offline
Sutradhar {admin}
 
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: CA, USA
Posts: 44,931
echarcha has a reputation beyond reputeecharcha has a reputation beyond reputeecharcha has a reputation beyond reputeecharcha has a reputation beyond reputeecharcha has a reputation beyond reputeecharcha has a reputation beyond reputeecharcha has a reputation beyond reputeecharcha has a reputation beyond reputeecharcha has a reputation beyond reputeecharcha has a reputation beyond reputeecharcha has a reputation beyond repute
Re: New book says Nehru's stubbornness led to war with China in 1962

ashdoc, since you are good at all this history stuff, can you please search for a phrase 'From sofa to Nefa' or 'from sofa to nifa' in context of Nehru and China war.
__________________
eCharcha.com
-Loud and Proud Desi Opinions
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
China-Taiwan military balance decisively tilts in favour of China ashdoc Defense 3 March 14th, 2011 11:12 AM
1962 war - boring details of actual fighting ashdoc Defense 13 April 5th, 2009 09:09 AM
how 1962 war started ashdoc Defense 20 April 4th, 2009 11:11 AM
Why China attacked India in 1962? what are future dangers from China to us? yrpude Defense 2 November 25th, 2001 12:01 PM


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 02:03 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Site Copyright © eCharcha.Com 2000-2012.